India

NEW DELHI: The hearing in the proceedings the Supreme Court had initiated suo motu for inclusion of safeguards to reduce instances of death penalty took an interesting turn with majority of the lawyers present declaring themselves to be abolitionists.While the SC had limited the application of death penalty only to the ‘rarest of rare’ cases, there is a strong feeling that its use should be further minimised by expanding the list of “mitigating factors” which can help a death sentence convict escape the gallows, and also by coming out with precise definitions of the attenuating considerations.As a bench comprising Chief Justice D Y Chandrachud and Justices J B Pardiwala and Manoj Misra readied the ground for commencement of hearing in the suo motu proceedings before a five-judge Constitution bench in January, amicus curiae Sidharth Dave said two major reforms in the sentencing process, for offences punishable with death penalty, needs to be considered.State govt vs Governors: Supreme Court raises questions over delay in Bill approvalFirst, persons convicted of such offences should be given adequate time post-conviction to enable them to produce adequate material that could persuade the trial courts or constitutional courts to consider whether these material constituted adequate mitigating circumstances for non-award of the highest punishment under the penal laws.

To facilitate this, the courts must follow a uniform time gap between conviction and sentencing, Dave said.Second, the SC would be required to deliberate on the necessity of periodic psychological evaluation of the convict in heinous offences, for which award of death sentence is provided for in the penal laws, to understand whether the person is fit to be executed, he said, adding the in the three-tier justice delivery system, a person spends on an average more than a decade before the criminal case attains finality with a decision from the SC.Should an incarcerated convict living under the dehumanising shadow of death penalty for a decade or more during the pendency of his appeal in the HC or SC be ordered to be executed without his periodic psychological evaluation and placing of such reports before the concerned courts, he asked.National Law University Delhi’s Project 39A through senior advocate Raju Ramachandran supported Dave and argued for provisioning adequate time gap between conviction and sentencing in a case to allow the convict to place mitigating circumstances before the court for non-award of death penalty.

When the bench scheduled the hearing before a five-judge bench in January, both Dave and Raju said that they were pro abolition of the death penalty.The SC in Bachan Singh case in 1983 had upheld the constitutionality of the death sentence but ruled that it could be imposed only in the ‘rarest of rare’ cases and had provisioned for an opportunity to the convict to show to the court the mitigating circumstances.

The SC had initiated the suo motu proceedings last year for framing guidelines on consideration of mitigating circumstances by courts while awarding death sentences after noticing the lack of a uniform framework in this regard.While referring the issue to five-judge bench, the SC last year had said, “It is also a fact that in all cases where imposition of capital punishment is a choice of sentence, aggravating circumstances would always be on record, and would be part of the prosecution’s evidence, leading to conviction, whereas the accused can scarcely be expected to place mitigating circumstances on the record, for the reason that the stage for doing so is after conviction.”





Unlimited Portal Access + Monthly Magazine - 12 issues-Publication from Jan 2021


Buy Our Merchandise (Peace Series)

 


Contribute US to Start Broadcasting



It's Voluntary! Take care of your Family, Friends and People around You First and later think about us. Its Fine if you dont wish to contribute and if you wish to contribute then think about the Homeless first and Feed them. We can survive with your wishes too :-). You can Buy our Merchandise too which are of the finest quality.

Debit/Credit/UPI

UPI/Debit/Credit

Paytm


STRIPE





53