Russia

As Moscow's invasion of Ukraine enters its third week, a pall has fallen over Russian artists, long crown jewels of a country whose fine arts are an eminent source of soft power.Superstar operatic soprano Anna Netrebko and renowned conductor Valery Gergiev are among the luminaries axed from performing on the global stages they have long graced but do cultural boycotts work?The freezing out of artists who have espoused pro-Kremlin views or who receive funding from the Russian state -- recalls similar measures taken over apartheid-era South Africa or against Israeli institutions in solidarity with Palestinians as part of the BDS movement.Jane Duncan of the University of Johannesburg, who has studied the power of such boycotts as political change agents, said isolation campaigns based on culture as well as sports can be "highly effective, because they can have a huge psychological impact.""Russia over a number of centuries now has prided itself on its intellectual, artistic and sporting achievements.
It's become part and parcel of its identity and its projection of soft power globally," the academic told AFP."I think we've already seen that there's a lot of dissent within Russia about the invasion of Ukraine, and a cultural boycott may well intensify that."Duncan cautioned, however, that a "blanket cultural boycott" could hurt anti-regime artists: in early 1980s South Africa, for example, she said, a form of "double censorship" emerged, where both the apartheid state and "artists who came from the liberation movements" were subject to shunning."That led to a situation where you couldn't actually hear the voices of the oppressed and the exploited expressed through art, through music, through drama, because they weren't allowed outside of the country."Emilia Kabakov, a multidisciplinary Ukrainian artist who has lived and worked with her husband Ilya in New York for decades, warned against punishing creatives and anyone simply on the basis of nationality."I know that Russian artists right now have problems," the 76-year-old born in the Soviet city of Dnipropetrovsk, now known as Dnipro in Ukraine, told AFP.But she suggested those Russians who live and work abroad may have a reason, saying: "Did anybody think, why are they here? Because they can't live there...
they want a normal life, unrestricted.""You don't have to work with collaborationists, but you have to work with Russians, and Ukrainians, and everybody else."Where is the line?The stance Kabakov evoked is the approach Duncan deemed appropriate to "steer clear" of boycotts based purely on nationality that "could lead to a very dark and difficult place."The scholar pointed to the BDS (Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions) movement as having a "much more sophisticated position on the cultural boycott" than was the original case in South Africa, promoting a selective rather than blanket ban.Queried by AFP, the cultural and academic boycott arm of the BDS movement said in a statement the measures they advocate for are "strictly institutional" and do "not target individuals."Leaders of major cultural institutions including New York's Metropolitan Opera, Paris' Philharmonic, and other European venues in recent weeks have said the scope of their boycott is focused on artists who back Russian President Vladimir Putin, not everyone with a Russian passport."If somebody is a tool of the state, they probably won't be working with the New York Philharmonic," the orchestra's CEO Deborah Borda told AFP."There is a line that is very clear," said French Culture Minister Roselyne Bachelot.
"We don't want to see representatives of Russian institutions or artists who clearly support Vladimir Putin."But in cases elsewhere, critics fear that line is blurred: the Polish Opera scrapped its production of Mussorgsky's 19th century opera Boris Godunov, and the Zagreb Philharmonic cut two Tchaikovsky compositions from a performance.Dostoevsky began trending after a Milan university tried to postpone a course about the classic Russian novelist behind "Crime and Punishment" who spent four years in a Siberian labor camp after reading banned books in Tsarist Russia.The university backtracked following the social media uproar.'Cancel culture'When it comes to contemporary artists' political responsibility, Duncan said "one can make the argument that producing the art and getting it out there is stance enough.""We also want to avoid putting artists on the spot to make political statements when perhaps they don't feel comfortable with doing that," she continued.Feeling pressure to speak out on Putin's war in Ukraine, Russian conductor Tugan Sokhiev left his posts at Moscow's Bolshoi and with the orchestra of Toulouse.In a lengthy statement, Sokhiev said he "will always be against any conflicts in any shape or form" but said he felt "forced to face the impossible option of choosing between my beloved Russian and beloved French musicians" so he quit both.Saying he and colleagues were "victims" of "cancel culture," the conductor insisted "we musicians are the ambassadors of peace.""Instead of using us and our music to unite nations and people, we are being divided and ostracized," he said.






Unlimited Portal Access + Monthly Magazine - 12 issues


Contribute US to Start Broadcasting - It's Voluntary!


ADVERTISE


Merchandise (Peace Series)

 


[Russia] - Trump Cuts To U.S.-Funded Media Put Reporters at Risk-- RSF


[Russia] - Putin Authorizes U.S. Hedge Fund to Buy Russian Securities


[Russia] - Russian Dissidents Stranded in Spain After Residency Requests Allegedly Denied


Only Rich People Should Be Allowed to Use Cryptocurrency, Russian Central Bank Says


[Russia] - Siberian City Bans Protest Against Protest Ban


[Russia] - Putin Seeks to Prolong Ukraine Peace Talks to His Advantage, Experts Say


[Russia] - Lithuania Blames Russian Military Intelligence for IKEA Arson Attack


Russia’s Superjet Airliner Completes First Test Flight With Domestic Engine


[Russia] - Ruble Strengthens to Highest Level Since June 2024 Ahead of Trump-Putin Talks


[Russia] - Fire at Oil Refinery in Southern Russia Extinguished 3 Days After Ukrainian Drone Strike


U.S. Hints at Ukraine Concessions Ahead of Trump-Putin Call


[Russia] - Russia Says Evacuated Over 350 Civilians From Retaken Areas in Kursk Region


[Russia] - Trump and Putin to Speak Tuesday About Ukraine War


Rubio, Lavrov Discuss Next Steps on Ukraine


Telegram Founder Durov Allowed to Temporarily Leave France


Russia Says Retook 2 More Villages in Border Region


[Russia] - Ukraine and Russia Down Hundreds of Drones Overnight


Putin Urges Ukrainian Troops in Kursk Region to Surrender


[Russia] - Putin Invites Venezuela's Maduro to Victory Day Parade in Moscow


G7 Warns Russia of New Sanctions Unless It Accepts Ukraine Ceasefire


Who Are the Russians Reportedly Delisted From the EU Sanctions Register


Russia Using Crypto in Chinese and Indian Oil Trade – Reuters


Trump Claims ‘Very Good Chance’ to End Ukraine War After Putin-Witkoff Meeting


[Russia] - Russia and China Urge Lifting Sanctions From Iran After Nuclear Talks in Beijing


[Russia] - EU Extends Sanctions Against Russia Following Delay From Hungary


Russia Lifts Abkhazia Travel Advisory Following Pro-Kremlin Leader’s Election Win


[Russia] - What Does Russia's Military Think About a Potential CeasefireThe Russian military appears hesitant of the United States' proposed 30-day ceasefire in Ukraine as President Vladimir Putin revealed severe concerns regarding Washington's initiati


Putin-Trump Meeting Dates to Be Discussed After U.S. Envoy Briefs White House on Ukraine Talks, Kremlin Says


[Russia] - Trump's Russia-Ukraine Envoy Excluded from Negotiations at Kremlin's Behest-- NBC News


Finnish Court Sentences Russian Ultranationalist to Life in Prison for War Crimes in Ukraine


Moscow Targeted by Second Ukrainian Drone Attack in a Week


Russian Favorability Toward U.S. Nearly Doubles Since Trump’s Return, Survey Finds


Russian-Tatar Composer Sofia Gubaidulina Dies at 93


Russian Army Regains Control Over Sudzha in Kursk Border Region


[Russia] - Zelensky Slams Putin's 'Very Manipulative' Statements on Ceasefire


[Russia] - Italy Summons Russian Envoy After 'Verbal Attacks' on President


[Russia] - Trump Says Putin's Ukraine Comments 'Promising' but Not 'Complete'U. S. President Donald Trump on Thursday said that Russian President Vladimir Putin had actually made a very promising declaration on a possible ceasefire in Ukraine but added


[Russia] - 'We Can not Trust the Russians': Ukrainians Skeptical Toward Ceasefire Hopes


[Russia] - Russia Supports Ceasefire Proposal in Ukraine, Putin Says, But 'Nuances' Remain


[Russia] - Russia Expands EU Entry Ban in Retaliation to War Anniversary Sanctons


[Russia] - Ukraine Accuses Russian Army of Executing 5 Captured Soldiers


[Russia] - Lukashenko Dismisses U.S. Ceasefire Proposal, Says Washington Has 'No Plan' for Ukraine War


[Russia] - ECHR Says Ukraine Failed to Prevent 2014 Odesa Clashes, Acknowledges Russian 'Propaganda' Role


[Russia] - Hungary Demands Sanctions Relief for Russian Billionaire Fridman Ahead of EU Sanctions Vote-- FEET


[Russia] - Kremlin Confirms U.S.-Russia Talks as Trump Envoy Lands in Moscow


[Russia] - FSB Arrests Man Over Bomb Packages Sent to Military Officials


[Russia] - Russian Army Retakes Sudzha in Kursk Border Region


Russian Army Downs 77 Ukrainian Drones Overnight


[Russia] - Putin Visits Kursk Region for First Time Since Ukraine's Offensive


[Russia] - Russian Inflation Hit 2-Year High in February


[Russia] - Russia Frees Journalist Convicted of 'Justifying Terrorism'


[Russia] - RIA Novosti Closes Athens Bureau After Greece Allegedly Denies Press Accreditation


[Russia] - U.S. 'Strongly Urges' Russia to Accept Ukraine Ceasefire Proposal


[Russia] - Unusual Siberian Tiger Kills Park Ranger in Far East Russia


[Russia] - Orthodox Easter Diplomacy: Kremlin and White House Pursue Fast-Tracked Putin-Trump Meeting


U.K. Police Arrest Russian Captain Over North Sea Ship Collision


4 Workers Killed in Ukrainian Attack on Russia’s Kursk Region, Governor Says


[Russia] - Russian Pro-War Figures, Military Bloggers Slam U.S. Ceasefire Proposal


Kremlin Awaits U.S. Briefing on Ukraine Ceasefire Plan, Top Spokesman Says


Videos Show Russian Troops Retaking Kursk Region’s Sudzha


Russian Missile Strike on Ukraine’s Odesa Kills 4 Syrians, Damages Cargo Ship


[Russia] - Russian and U.S. Spy Chiefs Hold First Talks in Years, Agree to Regular Contact


[Russia] - Ukraine Accepts 'Interim Ceasefire' as U.S. Resumes Intelligence Sharing and Military Aid


Hungary Says Russian Oil Supplies Halted After Ukraine Targets Druzhba Pipeline


[Russia] - Russia's First Imprisoned War Critic Gorinov Added to 'Terrorist and Extremist' List


‘War Has Come’: Ukrainian Drone Attack Leaves Moscow’s Suburbs Shaken


[Russia] - Russia's Budget Deficit Grows to 1.3% of GDP in January-February


[Russia] - 'Hey, Russians': In Kazakhstan, a Popular Satirist Battles 'Russophobia' Charges


[Russia] - Intermediate School Student Stabs Classmates in Nizhny Novgorod


Russian Army Reports Major Advances in Kursk Region After ‘Operation Pipeline’


[Russia] - Kremlin Says It Seeks Unity for Syria Amid Rising Violence and Unrest


Trump Envoy Witkoff Plans Second Meeting With Putin – Reports


At Least 3 Killed in ‘Largest Ever’ Ukrainian Drone Attack on Moscow


[Russia] - Moscow Targeted By 'Massive' Ukrainian Drone Attack


Journalists Jailed in Chad Over Alleged Wagner Ties


[Russia] - United States to Oppose 'Antagonistic' G7 Language on Russia, Rubio Says


Ukraine Risks Losing Kursk Foothold as Russia Pushes Forward


Ukraine Sending Reinforcements to Kursk Region Amid Russian Advances


Russian Resort Town Sues Owners of Tankers That Spilled Oil Into Black Sea


Romanian Presidential Hopeful with Suspected Moscow Ties Blocked from Election Re-Run


[Russia] - Russia Begins Naval Exercises With China and Iran in Gulf of Oman


Ukraine Will Propose Air and Naval Ceasefire During Saudi Arabia Talks – AFP


[Russia] - Chechen Official Decries 'Prejudiced' Telegram Ban in North Caucasus Regions


Russia’s Fingerprints Seen in Elections Across Eastern Europe


Russian Tall Ships Banned From Sail Amsterdam Festival


Russia Denies Reports About New Talks With U.S. in Saudi Arabia


Ukrainian Drones Strike Industrial Site in Russia’s Samara Region


Russia Expels 2 British Diplomats, Accuses Them of Espionage


[Russia] - Russia Claims Counteroffensive Into Ukraine's Sumy Region


Ukraine Says Russia Attacked With Over 100 Drones Overnight