India

The conglomerate has always denied that any of its public shareholders are related parties of the family.

Photo: Shutterstock.com7 min read Last Updated : Aug 12 2024 | 10:32 AM ISTBy Andy MukherjeeIt’s just as well for Narendra Modi that India’s parliament has been adjourned a day ahead of schedule.

Opposition parties would definitely have pounced on Hindenburg Research’s latest report to corner the prime minister on his friendship with Gautam Adani.

Lawmakers would have asked the government why the markets regulator is being so slow in completing its scrutiny of the controversial infrastructure tycoon.   That’s the thrust of the the New York-based short seller’s most recent allegations.

Its report Saturday didn’t make any fresh accusations against the businessman from Modi’s home state of Gujarat.

Instead, it asked if India’s stock-market watchdog can be trusted as an objective arbiter, given that its chairperson allegedly had a personal investment in an offshore fund linked to the “Adani money-siphoning scandal.”  Hindenburg’s original January 2023 report, in which it had accused the centi-billionaire of pulling the largest con in corporate history, caused the Adani Group’s market capitalization to crater by $150 billion.

The Supreme Court in New Delhi asked the Securities and Exchange Board of India to probe the allegations of stock-price manipulation, undisclosed related-party transactions and violation of minimum public shareholding, that were all vigorously denied by the conglomerate.  With Modi back in power for a third term, Adani’s fortunes are soaring once again.

His group’s shares have recouped nearly 90 per cent of last year’s loss.

And all this while, there’s no sign of a conclusion to Sebi’s court-directed investigation that was supposed to finish by April, long past its original two-month deadline set in early March last year.  Is the probe compromised because of an alleged conflict on the Sebi chair’s part? According to documents provided to Hindenburg by a purported whistleblower, Madhabi Puri Buch and her husband, Dhaval Buch, opened an account in 2015 with a wealth-management firm in Singapore to invest in a Mauritius-registered offshoot of a Bermuda-based fund.The Mauritian fund was run by an Adani director, and its ultimate parent was the vehicle through which two Adani associates had secretly amassed large positions in the conglomerate, according to an investigation by the Financial Times last year.

Adani said at the time that the “recycled allegations” in the FT article were a bid “to revive the meritless Hindenburg report.” According to the short-seller’s latest report, weeks before his wife became a whole-time member at the Indian regulator in April 2017, Dhaval requested the account to be registered solely in his name.

In February 2018, however, Madhabi wrote to the wealth manager from her private email, instructing the $872,000 investment to be redeemed.

In March 2022, she became the Sebi chair.

360 ONE WAM Ltd., the wealth-management firm, said Sunday that the Mauritius fund made no investment in Adani Group’s shares and over 90 per cent of its assets were consistently in bonds. The conglomerate has always denied that any of its public shareholders are related parties of the family.

In a fresh statement Sunday, it said Hindenburg’s latest report was a “malicious, mischievous and manipulative” selection of publicly available information.

Madhabi and Dhaval Buch described the allegations as an attempt at “character assassination.” Their finances were an “open book,” they said in an initial statement.

They didn’t challenge the authenticity of the whistleblower’s documents or deny their association with the Mauritius fund.  One of Hindenburg’s main questions was this: Why did Buch and her spouse use an investment vehicle run by a three-term director of Adani's flagship firm, “a multi-layered offshore fund structure with minuscule assets, traversing known high-risk jurisdictions” like Mauritius and Bermuda, when there exist “thousands of mainstream, reputable onshore Indian mutual fund products, an industry she now is responsible for regulating?” The Sebi chief and her husband gave an answer in a more detailed response Sunday.

The fund’s Chief Investment Officer Anil Ahuja, a former senior executive at 3i Group Plc, was Dhaval’s childhood friend, they said.

When he stepped down as CIO, the couple redeemed their shares.   Also, from April 2017 to March 2022, while she was already a regulator, Buch had a 100 per cent interest in a Singaporean consulting firm called Agora Partners.

She passed the shares to her husband two weeks after her appointment as the Sebi chair, Hindenburg alleged. Did Agora have publicly traded Indian firms as clients? The Sebi’s terms of service say that the chairman or whole-time member “shall not have any such financial or other interests as are likely to affect prejudicially his functions.” Buch said the consulting units — in Singapore and India — became dormant upon her Sebi appointment.

Dhaval got them going again, working “with prominent clients in Indian industry,” after retiring from Unilever Plc in 2019.

These changes were all disclosed to Sebi, the couple said in a joint press release.  Politicians on either side of the aisle are unlikely to get into the technical complexities.

Modi doesn’t speak about Adani, and his party is likely to deflect the new report as yet more evidence of an anti-India conspiracy in which an envious West is out to tarnish the reputation of a homegrown entrepreneur who’s helping end some of India’s most debilitating shortages of ports, airports, roads and energy. According to this narrative, the short seller is going after Buch only because she sent a show-cause notice, on June 27, to Hindenburg, its founder Nathan Anderson, as well as New York-based hedge fund manager Mark Kingdon and his Kingdon Capital Management, for allegedly violating the Sebi’s disclosure norms while profiting from the fall in Adani shares last year. But then, retribution doesn’t appear to be a strong motive.

Neither Hindenburg nor Kingdon is a Sebi-regulated entity.

There is precious little Buch can do to them by following up on the show-cause notice.

Hindenburg has previously said that it expects a ban or fines “to clamp down on the prospect of more criticism of Indian companies.” The real effect of Hindenburg’s report may be felt elsewhere.

In January, the Indian Supreme Court gave a big relief to Adani when it ruled that Sebi’s probe would be the last word — and that no more investigations were needed.

The Sebi chief’s alleged proximity to the situation is a new element for the judiciary to consider.

If nothing else, the court could ask for a speedy end to the inquiry.

In its own press statement Sunday, the Sebi said that it has concluded 23 out of its 24 investigations into the group, and the last one is close to completion.

“Where investigations have been completed, enforcement proceedings initiated are ongoing and appropriate actions are being taken,” the regulator added. The Congress Party, the main opposition, has already renewed its call for a joint probe by lawmakers into the Adani saga.

It was easy for the government to refuse this demand when Modi’s ruling party had an iron-clad grip on parliament.

This year’s election has eroded that advantage.

On Sunday, Congress leader Rahul Gandhi, who has kept up his attack against the prime minister for favoring large monopolies, asked the government to sack the Sebi chief.

He is unlikely to let the fodder from Hindenburg go to waste when parliament reconvenes for its winter session, in late November or early December. Disclaimer: This is a Bloomberg Opinion piece, and these are the personal opinions of the writer.

They do not reflect the views of www.business-standard.com or the Business Standard newspaperFirst Published: Aug 12 2024 | 10:32 AMIST





Unlimited Portal Access + Monthly Magazine - 12 issues-Publication from Jan 2021


Buy Our Merchandise (Peace Series)

 


Contribute US to Start Broadcasting



It's Voluntary! Take care of your Family, Friends and People around You First and later think about us. Its Fine if you dont wish to contribute and if you wish to contribute then think about the Homeless first and Feed them. We can survive with your wishes too :-). You can Buy our Merchandise too which are of the finest quality.


STRIPE


[India] - Torrent Power dedicates Rs 64,000 crore investment for green tasks


Air traffic soars as more passengers opt for direct flights to from India


[India] - Kenya awards $1.3 bn transmission offer to Adani amidst airport lease demonstrations


Rifle poking from bushes: How Donald Trump left newest assassination quote


Here's what India needs to accomplish its semiconductor ambitions


Shipbuilders from Japan, Korea keen to invest here: Sarbananda Sonowal


US lenders counter Byju's claim, says edtech has to repay full $1.2 bn


Piyush Goyal to launch Bharat Startup Knowledge Access Registry on Monday


Inside Elon Musk's mushrooming security device in Tesla factories


[India] - RBI plans to revamp currency management infra to accommodate future money needs


Reliance broadens trading area by 50% for non-food general merchandise


[India] - SOM Distilleries debuts in K'taka with Woodpecker beer, eyes 1,600 cr sales


Kejriwal to resign as CM in 2 days, requires public to offer decision


Development of tribals, poor, youth, women our priority: PM Modi in J'khand


[India] - FPIs inject Rs 27,856 cr in equities in Sept on US rate cut expectations


USFDA cites producing lapses at Zydus Lifesciences' Gujarat plant


[India] - Water purifier maker Livpure eying over 1 mn memberships within 4 years


Epsilon Advanced Materials plans Rs 9,000 cr anode facility in K'taka: MD


Mcap of 9 of top-10 most valued firms jump Rs 2 trn; Bharti Airtel sparkles


PM Modi to visit Jharkhand today to flag off 6 new Vande Bharat trains


Nitin Gadkari says he was offered support for PM's post, but he declined


[India] - Sebi exempts SHPL from making open offer for SpiceJet investors


OIL to invest Rs 25,000 cr in clean energy for net zero emissions by 2040


Congress fires fresh salvo against Sebi Chairperson Madhabi Puri Buch


[India] - Mcap of 9 of top-10 most valued firms jump Rs 2 trn; Bharti Airtel sparkles


PM Modi to go to Jharkhand today to flag off 6 new Vande Bharat trains


Encounter with terrorists underway in Kashmir's Poonch; area cordoned off


Investors to focus on US Fed interest rate decision this week: Analysts


Nitin Gadkari says he was used support for PM's post, but he declined


[India] - Sebi exempts SHPL from making open offer for SpiceJet investors


[India] - OIL to invest Rs 25,000 cr in tidy energy for net no emissions by 2040


Oberoi Grp family dispute: Delhi HC injuncts shares held by late PRS Oberoi


NCLT recalls order on Zee-Sony merger, allows withdrawal of scheme


OIL aims to drill 75-plus wells in FY25 using more rigs, newer tech: CMD


[India] - Govt raises import tax on crude, improved edible oils to support farmers


[India] - CCI finds Samsung, Xiaomi conspiring with Amazon, Flipkart: Report


[India] - Congress fires fresh salvo versus Sebi Chairperson Madhabi Puri Buch


LG Electronics picks banks for $1.5 billion listing of Indian unit


[India] - Byju's bankruptcy judgment in US comes as a surprise for Indian authorities


[India] - IPO-bound Ecom Express utilized inaccurate numbers in DRHP, says Delhivery


[India] - Short-sellers might target banks with big CRE exposure: RBI governor Das


[India] - E-commerce firm Flipkart equips sellers with tools ahead of flagship event


Majority of Adani group stocks settle lower, Adani Power down nearly 3%


[India] - Byju's bankruptcy ruling in US comes as a surprise for Indian official


Investors authorize Rs 3,000 crore fund raising plan, says SpiceJet


[India] - IPO-bound Ecom Express used inaccurate numbers in DRHP, says Delhivery


[India] - After 2 years, Ford takes road back to India to make e-cars for export


[India] - Short-sellers may target banks with big CRE direct exposure: RBI governor Das


[India] - E-commerce company Flipkart gears up sellers with tools ahead of flagship event


Bulk of Adani group stocks settle lower, Adani Power down almost 3%


[India] - Akums Drugs gets patent for formula to handle sickle cell disease


[India] - Zomato teams up with IRCTC to use food delivery service on trains


Our focus is on being a future all set business, says Rites CMD Mithal


[India] - Realme P2 Pro 5G, Pad 2 Lite launched in India: Check price, specifications and more


[India] - Akums Drugs gets patent for formula to manage sickle cell illness


[India] - Zomato teams up with IRCTC to provide food delivery service on trains


Arvind Kejriwal gets bail, but SC split on legality of CBI's arrest


Govt decides to rename Port Blair as Sri Vijaya Puram, says Amit Shah


Sebi chairperson Madhabi Puri Buch rubbishes Congress allegations


Our focus is on being a future prepared company, says Rites CMD Mithal


iPhone 16 series now available for pre-order in India, sale begins Sept 20


[India] - Realme P2 Pro 5G, Pad 2 Lite introduced in India: Check cost, specifications and more


[India] - Tamil Nadu labour minister to satisfy Samsung officials to fix strike


Kalpataru Projects International bags orders worth Rs 2,774 crore


[India] - NaBFID should end up being self-sustainable, not rely on govt: RBI dy guv


As regulators get hard, Big Tech's simple ride is pertaining to an end


[India] - Sebi considers new stricter guidelines to suppress risks as small IPOs boom


HDFC in talks with int'l banks to offload $1 bn in loans to cut credit book


[India] - Paytm to focus on core biz; deliver success quickly: CEO Sharma


[India] - Durex makes India condom push for females, rural consumers with lubes, advertisements


[India] - NITI Aayog group proposes different law to deal with public health crises


SpaceX's competing AST SpaceMobile soars 1,300%; now comes the satellite launch


Google's AI model deals with EU analysis from guard dog over personal privacy rules


Highest frequency of road crash deaths from 9 pm to 2 am, 89% men: Report


EVs get Rs 14k crore double shot: Boost for ambulances, buses, trucks


[India] - Samsung plans global job cuts of approximately 30% in some departments: Report


SpiceJet to pay elderly couple complete refund for flight cancelled in Covid


Investors demanded sustainability over rapid growth: GoMechanic's Kakkar


Tata Steel, UK govt indication GBP 500 mn grant agreement for Port Talbot job


Vedanta Resources gets $900 mn via first dollar bond issue to prepay loans


[India] - Sebi tweaks margin trading centers' structure to relieve collateral burden


UK gets improved terms for 2,500 workers as it recommits to Tata Steel deal


IndiGo pays lowered Rs 70 lakh fine to BCAS over Mumbai airport occurrence


[India] - CCI offers nod to Dixon Technologies to acquire stake in Aditya Infotech


[India] - PhonePe, Liquid Group tie up to expand UPI QR payment service in Singapore


IndiGo pays reduced Rs 70 lakh fine to BCAS over Mumbai airport event


[India] - CCI provides nod to Dixon Technologies to acquire stake in Aditya Infotech


[India] - PhonePe, Liquid Group bind to expand UPI QR payment service in Singapore


[India] - Lulu Group aiming to up agri sourcing from India to Rs 15,000 cr in 2 yrs


[India] - ONGC Videsh's focus on stakes in oil, gas possessions amid energy transition


[India] - CCI clears proposed merger of Tata Motors Finance into Tata Capital


Infosys, Proximus Group come together to drive brand-new organization opportunities


Tata Motors lowers prices of its EV model range by approximately Rs 3 lakh


[India] - HCLTech to show GenAI-based chatbot, other services at SEMICON India 2024


[India] - M refutes Congress allegations versus Sebi chief's other half Dhaval Buch


[India] - Digital firms with Rs 500 crore turnover should seek CCI approval for M As


[India] - AI Express to phase out biz class seats by 2025; to have 100 planes by Dec


Carlyle Aviation will write off $40 million of lease arrears: SpiceJet


[India] - Lockheed Martin-Tata pact might make it possible for regional C-130J Super Hercules production


Huawei unveils tri-fold smartphone, raising competition with Apple in China


Tata Electronics, ASMPT sign pact for semiconductor equipment infra


JSW Neo Energy bags 600 MW wind-solar hybrid project from MSEDCL


Adani looks for Md Yunus' assistance in getting $800 mn in payments cleared


[India] - Apple provider Jabil to establish Rs 2,000 crore mfg unit in Tiruchirapalli


Boeing's shares increase after tentative labour offer that could prevent strike


[India] - Civil aviation ministry trying to address SpiceJet's issues: Rammohan Naidu


Adani looks for Md Yunus' help in getting $800 mn in payments cleared


[India] - Apple supplier Jabil to establish Rs 2,000 crore mfg system in Tiruchirapalli


Kenyan court suspends govt plan to allow Adani to operate main airport


Boeing's shares increase after tentative labour offer that might avert strike


[India] - Civil air travel ministry attempting to deal with SpiceJet's problems: Rammohan Naidu


KKR's Agrawal calls industrial infra 'next big thing' in asset class


Sebi raises constraints on 16 entities in Infosys insider trading case


Audible to begin creating AI voice replicas of choose audiobook narrators


Airtel Finance uses FD service, partners with NBFCs, small financing banks


[India] - JSW Infra okays Rs 2,359 cr capex for growth at Jaigarh, Dharamtar ports


[India] - 4 agreements signed in between Indian, UAE entities in energy sector


Agrochemicals export likely to touch Rs 80,000 cr in 4 yrs: ACFI-EY report


India needs more trade, and being inside RCEP is better than staying out


Apple's upcoming iPhone to break grounds with shift into age of AI


GST Council to ponder on taxation of insurance premium, online gaming


Jaishankar arrives in Riyadh to attend India-GCC Foreign Ministers' Meeting


[India] - US elections: Trump pledges 100% tariff for nations that avoid dollar


[India] - MSDE, Swiggy tie up to supply skilling, employment opportunities


[India] - Byju's counter, states BDO's lack of interaction with IRP suspicious


Tata Power awards contracts worth Rs 11,481 cr to regional providers in Odisha


[India] - United States elections: Trump vows 100% tariff for nations that shun dollar


[India] - MSDE, Swiggy tie up to provide skilling, employment opportunities


[India] - MSDE, Swiggy bind to supply skilling, job opportunity


New code for medical devices mandates complaint decisions within 90 days


Wockhardt denies Carol Info rent payment allegations, link with Sebi orders


[India] - Vinesh Phogat, Bajrang Punia used by Cong as pawns: Brij Bhushan Singh


[India] - Byju's counter, says BDO's absence of communication with IRP suspicious


Tata Power awards agreements worth Rs 11,481 cr to regional providers in Odisha


[India] - Byju's auditor BDO resigns after start of insolvency proceedings, firm states


Bomb threat: Vistara sends new aircraft to fly passengers from Turkey





53